VisuaLint: Sketchy In Situ Annotations of Chart Construction Errors

Aspen Hopkins, Michael Correll, Arvind Satyanarayan

Examples of VisuaLint for six types of chart construction errors: (a) inexpressive size encodings; (b) dual axis charts with differing scales; (c) perceptually ineffective color encodings; (d) missing legends; and, (e) truncated axes.

Abstract

Chart construction errors, such as truncated axes or inexpressive visual encodings, can hinder reading a visualization, or worse, imply misleading facts about the underlying data. These errors can be caught by critical readings of visualizations, but readers must have a high level of data and design literacy and must be paying close attention. To address this issue, we introduce VisuaLint: a technique for surfacing chart construction errors in situ. Inspired by the ubiquitous red wavy underline that indicates spelling mistakes, visualization elements that contain errors (e.g., axes and legends) are sketchily rendered and accompanied by a concise annotation. VisuaLint is unobtrusive — it does not interfere with reading a visualization — and its direct display establishes a close mapping between erroneous elements and the expression of error. We demonstrate five examples of VisualLint and present the results of a crowdsourced evaluation (N = 62) of its efficacy. These results contribute an empirical baseline proficiency for recognizing chart construction errors, and indicate near-universal difficulty in error identification. We find that people more reliably identify chart construction errors after being shown examples of VisuaLint, and prefer more verbose explanations for unfamiliar or less obvious flaws.

Citation

VisuaLint: Sketchy In Situ Annotations of Chart Construction Errors

Aspen Hopkins, Michael Correll, Arvind Satyanarayan

Computer Graphics Forum (Proc. EuroVis), 2020.

Bibtex

@article{2020-visualint,
 title = {{VisuaLint: Sketchy In Situ Annotations of Chart Construction Errors}},
 author = {Aspen Hopkins AND Michael Correll AND Arvind Satyanarayan},
 journal = {Computer Graphics Forum (Proc. EuroVis)},
 year = {2020},
 url = {http://vis.csail.mit.edu/pubs/visualint}
}

Materials

Videos

EuroVis 2020 Talk